David Portnoy recalls his online spat with Justin Gaethje: “He threatened to beat me up.”

David Portnoy

David Portnoy has recalled his recent back-and-forth with UFC lightweight Justin Gaethje (23-4 MMA) whilst on the ‘Joe Rogan Experience’ podcast earlier this week. 

The Barstool founder has been doing the rounds within the Mixed Martial Arts community ever since signing the popular fan favorites Paddy Pimblett (20-3 MMA) and Molly McCann (13-5 MMA) to exclusive content creator this past year. 

Portnoy has been an avid supporter of them both and has been seen cage-side for both of the pair’s recent fights. 

While Molly McCann’s latest outing against Erin Blanchfield (10-1 MMA) didn’t go as planned at UFC 281. The 45-year-old was in attendance to lead the cheers for Paddy Pimblett as he co-headlined against Jared Gordon (19-6 MMA) in the last pay-per-view of the year at UFC 282 in Las Vegas. 

READ MORE:  Jon Jones Reveals Staggering Success For UFC 309 Event

Despite a controversial decision victory for ‘The Baddy’, the scouser was in full voice following his win shouting to UFC President Dana White for Fight of the Night honors in the immediate aftermath.

David Portnoy continued his support for Pimblett by echoing the chant for the fight of the night whilst walking Pimblett backstage as well as on social media, which didn’t sit too well with a lot of fighters including the former UFC lightweight champion Justin Gaethje.

Justin Gaethje threatened to beat up David Portnoy

Following this week’s episode of the ‘Joe Rogan Experience’, David Portnoy recounted what was the cause of his Twitter beef with Gaethje. 

READ MORE:  Stamp Fairtex Promises a Comeback and Reveals Her 2025 Return Plans After Knee Injury 'I lost my focus.'

[Gaethje] threatened to beat me up,” Portnoy exclaims.

“That’s not saying much. Your producer could beat me up. That’s not much of a threat. I’ve never been in a physical altercation in my life.”

“After the fight, Paddy is saying, ‘fight off the night!’ The third round, they didn’t throw a punch. It wasn’t fight of the night, but he was talking fight of the night. Paddy’s our guy. So, we’re saying, ‘Fight of the night, fight of the night!’ 

“He [Gaethje] got mad at us. He’s like, ‘You’re trying to steal money from the actual fighters who won fight of the night.’ We’re like no we didn’t … People littered the comments that he was out with a third-world dictator [Ramzan Kadyrov]. So, I hit him back with that. We just said Paddy was fight of the night, you were out with the dictator, one of the worst guys on the planet.”


This past November, Gaethje was spotted in Chechnya alongside fellow UFC fighters Kamaru Usman and Henry Cejudo. The Trio was reportedly where there at the invitation of Chechen dictator Ramazan Kadyrov. 

READ MORE:  Tom Aspinall Spots ‘Openings’ in Jon Jones’ Game After UFC 309 KO

During the pair’s social media spat, Justin Gaethje denied the claims of meeting with Kadyrov, instead claiming he was there after accepting an invitation to a birthday party for the warlord’s son. 

Joe Rogan responded comically warning David Portnoy it’s probably best not to antagonize the most violent man in MMA. Although, Rogan isn’t too concerned for Portnoy’s safety if the two ever met in person.

What do you make of the back-and-forth between David Portnoy and Justin Gaethje?